Lexington Pizza Parlour

This is what a neighbourhood Italian should be. Lovely trattoria. We only had pizza but the menu looked excellent, some great dishes on there.

Good food on lexington avenue. Recommended Italians restaurant. The pizza 🍕 is the best.They add authentic 20% tip - that’s I don’t like

This is a sophisticated pizza restaurant with a great range of food and drink options. It was a lovely place to have dinner as the sun set, and there were really cute fairy lights all around the outside area, making it an even more magical experience. Everyone at my table very much enjoyed their meal, and we hope to come back here at some point.

We love this place! Their chicken parm is amazing, their pizza is my favorite on the east side, and the desserts from their partner, Harlem Baking Co., are simply incredible (highlights on the cheesecakes).My partner and I have been here many times, and it’s our top spot to take family and friends when they visit.While most of our experiences here have been excellent, we did have one recent interaction where a server seemed a bit impatient while explaining menu options. It wasn’t a huge issue – we might have caught him on a bad day, and it didn’t take away from the great food or welcoming atmosphere we’ve come to expect.Overall, this place is a true gem, and we’re always excited to return!

I absolutely love Lexington Pizza Parlour! Every visit is a delight. The food is always outstanding—my personal favorite is the chicken with mashed potatoes, paired perfectly with a glass of their mulled wine. My friend can’t get enough of their pizza; its some of the best in the city!The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, and the staff truly makes a difference. Patrick, our server, is fantastic—always smiling, attentive, and makes sure we have everything we need to feel right at home. This is what real hospitality is all about! Highly recommend if youre looking for delicious food and a friendly place to unwind.

Outstanding! My wife and I had the lasagna and steak. Good music. Food was fantastic. Owner is a French chef? This place looks like a pizza shop, but they have live music in the evenings and the food is on par with anything I’ve paid top dollar for in Midtown or Downtown.

FOOD POISONINGSo, my friend and I had lunch here yesterday, 3.25 and my friend spoke highly of it so I went and ordered their clam fettuccine. It was good! Or at least that’s what my starving self felt at that time. My afternoon went on without anything else to eat but that lunch. When I was on my way home, I suddenly felt being nauseous and dizzy that I thought I was gonna pass out! My heart was racing and as I got out of the subway, I started throwing up! I got home and all I could do was to curl up on my couch and throw up some more. It was a rough night. I realized then that I was having food poisoning.I don’t know how that clam was prepared but the minced one looked like it came from a bottle or can or I guess, not fresh.I don’t know if I can come back here again. It is traumatizing. I have never had any food poisoning in my life EVER! Until yesterday. I’m so sad that I don’t look forward on coming back to this place even though they looked really good and our waitress was so nice and friendly!I hope the management take this seriously. It is not a pleasant feeling and the food needs a really meticulous attention especially when it comes to seafood.I’d still give this one star only because their beef ribs was so tender and good!

The customer service is amazing! This restaurant has outdoor seating. The cheesecake is a MUST, they come in adorable little mason jars and the flavor is just out of this world! The food was great as well. Definitely coming again!

I’ve dined here and delivered from here a few times. Overall great, but there are some times when the taste is mediocre. Nice outdoors brunch spot, but were visited by many bees who were obsessed with my food in picture. I removed the orange thinking that must be what they were after, but turns out it’s the hollandaise sauce

We went to this restaurant because they were participating in an Open Streets weekend. They had spacious sidewalk seating, awnings and umbrellas to protect from the sun. We had an uneven number so they graciously rearranged a table and chairs for us. The staff wore masks and gloves at all time. We arrived for brunch because of the unlimited cocktail option and the mimosa that I purchased came in an individual carafe. The brunch dish I chose, Le Sandwich, was a wonderful combination of eggs, bacon and mozzarella cheese nestled between two slices of french toast with a maple dipping sauce. With the drinks flowing, we closed out the brunch window and ended up staying through for an early dinner. I ordered two really fantastic dishes, the mushroom rice balls and the seasonal burrata which came with watermelon and toast points. I look forward to dining here during the colder months if indoor dining resumes.

This is my favorite hidden gem of a pizza parlor - and it’s so much more than just that. The meals beyond just the pizza are delicious. I’ve been ordering in pizza and dining out at LPP for years. I had a few Birthday celebrations there too — Which were always amazing!!! The pizza is incredible, pasta unforgettable and memories made will always stay with me. I bring guests from out of town and they all love it. Thank you to Maria and the entire team for always making it a joy to eat in (or out!) with you.I’m happy to also say as of 2023– I’d still continue to rate 5 stars! Love the pizza so much, crispy dough and delicious flavors.

Happy hour sign out the front is intentionally misleading - anyone reading it would think draft beer is $5, in reality it’s $7. Don’t do this, it annoys people. If the sign had said $7 we still would have come in and left happy. Is it worth it to cheat your customers?

The East Harlem place is very small. This is NOT fine dining. It ruined my date night. Its a pizza bodega space with a couple of uneven tables. The music was tragic. I ordered Chicken Marsala and the wine sauce was grossly sweet. The mushrooms were textureless. The main problem was that the chicken was uneven temperature as if it was prepared in the microwave. Then this homestyle carrot cake in the jar was pathetic and inedible.

Went as a family and had pizza and brunch menu (frittata), everything was very fresh and tasty. The decor is cute and the staff is very friendly. A lovely neighbourhood gem, it’s small though so recommend booking if you’re more than 4 people, although a party of 7 came for lunch when we were there and they managed to accommodate them. Recommended!

Dined here on a Friday night. Restaurant was busy and we had a great time! The food is very very good and the atmosphere is very intimate and fun. I very much recommend you visit this restaurant - there is a cozy feel and the people are so nice. I happen to know the owner well and he is such a great guy. Highly recommend.

So the food was amazing. I just wish we had gotten more especially at the price. They serve a main dish at an appetizer size portion , the size of a palm . I’m curious as to what the business model might be and what are some of the factors as to why they charge main course prices to appetizer size meals. Being a Harlem resident we ‘re all familiar with gentrification and how it impacts our community but you can get the same dish two times the size for the same price on 110th St. and 2nd Ave. but again we may just be paying for the atmosphere, but the food was amazing. I’m just curious as to how they create their price markings, especially if the desire is to gain more customers not just those coming into our community through gentrification.

Great service, great prices and delicious food. The drinks were especially good value, and make sure you try the Harlem Baking Co desserts!

Delicious pizza, I loved the balsamic vinegar and artichoke. They have a nice patio to sit at and enjoy your pizza.

A reliable neighborhood favorite. Well priced and portioned. Great atmosphere and service.

We went here after searching for a place to eat, and thank goodness we came to this spot. We ordered the 12” Margarita Pizza and the Rigatoni Bolognese. The pizza was delicious, the crust was crispy and flavorful and the sauce with the melted mozzarella was sweet and savory. The Rigatoni was to die for, it had such a exquisite meaty taste with a sweet and herbal taste from the tomatoes and spices. Lastly we also got the Chocolate mousse from Harlem Baking Co., and it was fabulous. The mousse was not too sweet and the soft airy texture melted in your mouth. Sammy was very friendly, informative and a great server! I would definitely recommend this place!!

Amazing place! Food is sooo delicious! Found this place when my husband was in the hospital. Went multiple times and will continue to come for the duration of the stay. Staff so kind and accommodating as well! Can’t say enough great things!

I am going to cry about this, Lexington Pizza Parlour is one of my favorite place ever, It has a great time and great food such as pizza, spaghetti, shrimp and even more like that. As a December 15 2024, we are sad for lexington pizza parlour will be shutdown and it will be no longer business after December 15, 2024. I will be miss for all. This a best food ever, and this is my opinion.

We are italian and here we found good italian food. Risotto is always at the American style but it was great. Service is very kind and the place is cozy. Well done!

5-stars just for my plate! 10-stars for the food. This place is a must. The food was absolutely spectacular.

A bit thin on the sauce. Heavy on cheesepizzA.Keep o. Keeping on. This pizza ks a pizza shop pizza 🍕

I ordered a pizza for pick up. I was given a Time on line to pick it up and was there 15 minutes early. My pizza was ready. When I got home it was cold like it had been out all day and was not fed hot warm. I’ve had good experiences eating here in person but will never get pizza to go again because no on should be served an old cold pizza.

Found this gem while spending days at Mt Sinai hospital after son’s surgery. The service was excellent…the food was delicious…and the playlist was perfect. We had the Manicotti and the Roman artichokes. I will definitely make a special trip to this humble yet refined spot.

Food was alright. The chefs gave my little brother a dessert on the house.

Fun place, brick oven pizza and chicken parmigiana were both really good. There was also an added bonus with the music and energy coming from the 101st st pop up event.

WOW! Get to this restaurant immediately. We had a late lunch on a Friday after a couple of museums in the area. Covered sidewalk tables were available to make it more special.The service was impeccable and so friendly and helpful for tourists.The food - top meal in Manhattan. I ordered the watermelon and burrata salad and it was seriously one of the most amazing meals I’ve had. My companion ordered a meatball calzone and was more than delighted. He has a heartily appetite and couldn’t quite finish it - definitely something to share.I cannot say enough good things about this place and cannot wait to go back on my next trip.

A few days back I visited the establishment with my partner and a friend for a quick lunch. The food was average, the service was above average. Given the latter, my partner, who covered the bill, wrote-in a 25% tip while paying the full bill with a credit card. The next day we checked the cerdit card account to find the bill was posted but without the offered tip. He visisted the establishment to apologize to the wiater for the misshap and handed him his well deserved tip in cash. However, a day later the credit card bill was reposted inclusive of the tip. He approached the credit card company with the facts requesting a credit for the tip which he had already honored in cash. The establishment denied the facts and Bank of America (the credit card company) dismiss the claim based on his honesty and integrity. Sad! Honesty is so little valued in our society these days.

Had delivery. Never again. Delivery man calls and tell me hes in the lobby but instead was outside and far away from the building. Get upstairs and open the box of pizza for my kids only to see that the pizza inside was all mangled and stuck together like a ball. It looked as if it been dropped multiple times.We go by first impressions. This will definitely be the first & last time I will order from there. I should have stuck with Dreamers Pizza.

The best restaurant in the area - amazing staff, great food, wonderful atmosphere - truly the highlight of our neighborhood.

Me and my family went to celebrate my birthday. But they said we only have seats outside. The weather was cold outside. We said we want to sit inside. Kid you not they had no one sitting inside. We felt so disrespected and not wanted there. They lost a very good customer. We walked out. So we went to Angelos Coal Oven Pizzaria. Awesome spot.

What Happened???My husband and I have been going here for years!We were so disappointed,Our last visit was scary. Food was not good! Utensils were dirty ..they had baked on red sauce on them. Plates were also dirty/ greesy.OMG! I WAS SODISGUSTED. We left after appetizers. The bathroom, was also a disaster area. ..leaking water everywhere...and the smell of urine was unbearable.It was horrendous. I cant! I couldnt even finish appetizers. We just paid our bill and left. OMG! It was just dirty alltogether and outdoor shed where we sat today is falling apart. Holes in the floor..garbage on ground. So disappointing!Nothing else to add..I used to love this place.😔

This is a hidden gem, something about the name that makes me to always walk passed it with no interest. But when I finally tried their food it was absolutely delicious. Their artichoke is a die for. The owner was gracious and kind. Their happy hour is ridiculously good

Have visited twice - once dining in and once for takeout. Dining in, we absolutely loved it. Such great pizza at a great price. Takeout was a pretty different experience and we didn’t love our pizzas, even though we ordered the same ones. Open to trying again in person!

I like this place. Been here several times. Cute place. Outdoor seating. Good food and service. They have a nice brunch. And the cheesecake ohhh yummy love the biscotti crust one.

They do serve good food. They do. However I heard from a friend that back in June 5 2021, a soldier from the U.S. Army went and ate with a friend. The soldier paid a good tip just to end up kind of discriminated by the same waiter because he was in uniform just after he ate. The rating review from me is a 0 because of that.To the owner or owners of the pizza restaurant: correct your waiters. Thank You.

I love this little gem in my neighborhood, such good food, space is perfect, service also on point. I recommend anything on the menu.

Great mom and pop shop that I plan to visit again. The food and service was great. We had a large group and they were so accommodating.Give them a try!

I like this place, always have. Not the largest portions but everything is very good. The atmosphere is pretty chill too. Theres a bunch of restaurants in a row on this block and a half in Spanish Harlem. Definitely a go to place.

It is one of the best piza restaurants in town. Always good. Solid staff, too. This is not a fancy place, and it doesnt need to because the food speaks for itself.

When we are able to come here we always do. The pizza is great and the owner/manager is always extra pleasant. The pizza is amazing and everything we have tried has been superb. I highly recommend making a stop and try a slice. One day we will try the other dishes and I will further update my review.

I was on the eat side of Harlem and was in the mood for pasta so a friend recommended this place. They offer both in door and outdoor dining and it wasn’t super fancy or upscale which was great. I had on my work clothes and didn’t want to feel out of place. The service was great and my food came pretty fast. I ordered the spaghetti carbonara which was delicious. I’ll definitely be coming back to try out some of the other pasta dishes.

The food is pretty good. The portions are rather on the small size, tho.

Pizza/ rice balls ITS A MUST HAVE 😋 food is so delicious,fresh customer service is super friendly,great atmosphere and dessert’s are YUMMY we always end up having some to go.

So I really liked this place. The ambience here is good and the food is amazingly delicious. We ordered a pizza “Di buffala & arugula” which was super tasty, we also had two Sicilian slices one of chicken and the other of four cheese.The only reason why I give just 4 stars is that the prices are in some way high, I mean $22 for a thin crust pizza is a lot even more that there are places that serve oven pizzas as delicious as this place with the same quality and they don’t charge that much.We ended up paying around $40 just for one pizza and two Sicilian slices, no drinks.So if you want to come just keep in mind the prices.A feed back for the pizzeria: you should add tomato sauce to the Sicilian four cheese. We liked it but it would be way better with tomato sauce on the base.

Food is AMAZING! Penne vodka is the best I’ve ever had. The night ends with the perfect jar of deserts after a hearty meal. Great happy hour and wine selection too!

Great food! Whether take-away or on site! A great spot for the neighborhood!

We needed a take-out pizza, and came away with some excellent slices, both New York and Chicago styles. Food is terrific, very affordable, and we felt very relieved after so many bad NYC food experiences on our vacation. The restaurant is also quite cozy and comfortable, with open panels to the street and jazz music in the background. Very nice! If youre in Spanish Harlem or the Upper East Side, pay these guys a visit. Much thanks!

Havent been in person but have had delivery from here, got the impression that this was slightly nicer than usual pizza-fare. We enjoyed the carbonara a lot, but thought the arancini were a tad overpriced.

I thought that we were going for pizza. Turns out that they have an extended menu. We had delicious mussels, a sensational salad, shared a branzino that was one of the most delicious that I have eaten. The men ate delicious pork chops (from the specials) again fabulous. That was our first time there. Cant wait to go back!

I had the Marsala Chicken w/ Linguine and Mushrooms. The food was delightful and the service was really good.

Ate in the well heated outdoor space. Their Burrata is fantastic. They make a simple but perfect arugula salad and we also had the duck. Great, friendly service and delicious food.

Such a great place! Truly a gem. Amazing staff, great service, and delicious food. Always happy to have it!! Pictured is the penne vodka! Super yummy!

Very tasty pizza. Toddler strongly approves.Edit: been there many times, today pizza was stale... Hope it wont be a pattern

I ordered a lasagna last night and I couldn’t eat it because it was too acid, the sauce had a terrible taste.

Weve had brunch there, which was delicious and lovely, but the pizza that we ordered for delivery last week was the best weve had in the realm of take-out. And, since we ordered too much, it heated up very well the following day.

Ordered delivery through Slice. Food turned up 40 minutes late and stone cold. No apology or explanation from delivery driver. Other than temperature, pizza itself was fine but nothing special. Plenty of other places to order from...

Ordered once from here. Frutti dimare. Not terrible, not good. But second time I ordered I asked for garlic bread....... Plain old garlic bread. THEY TOLD ME THEY DIDNT HAVE IT!!!!! WHAT KIND OF ITALIAN JOINT DOESNT HAVE GARLIC BREAD????? Enough said!!!!!

*FOOD POISIONING*I had a craving for a delicious Sicilian slice of white pizza, but unfortunately, the service was terrible. Even after trying the white pizza for a second time, I ended up getting food poisoning from it AGAIN. The pizza was barely in the oven for a few seconds before being hastily thrown into a brown bag and handed to me. To make matters worse, the cashier, a young Hispanic man who did not wear gloves, handled my food and took my money WITH THE SAME BARE HANDS. The person who handled my pizza, an older Hispanic man who also did not wear gloves, was equally unprofessional. Both of them treated me (a Hispanic female) with disrespect and hostility for no reason, giving me attitude whenever I asked a simple question.This is unacceptable and something everyone should be cautious about when coming here.The restaurant is average, resembling a small pizzeria attempting fine dining. Its located in Spanish Harlem and has a questionable reputation with the Hispanic community.

We love the food so so much at Lexington pizza!! Just yum!!!

Both the carbonara and penne vodka were good!Fair prices

We were at an event close by went in to ask about the menu . Just when my daughters were looking to sit I asked the gentleman at the register if the had beef patties he was immediately said no (ok) then he proceeded to inform me that they do not have fried wings, French fries or fast foods ,very unwelcoming.Every restaurant should serve as they want. But his demeanor was so offensive. Why would he assume i would only eat fried foods.Maybe he should not serve at this neighborhood. Needless to say i did not try the old pasta .

Pizza here is decent, place is clean and Its a welcome addition to the area.The Margarita pizza, however, is a disappointment because it does not have fresh mozzarella, which is what you expect when you order this item. It has regular processed cheese- perhaps the slightest hint of fresh mozzarella mixed in, but its not whats advertised. If the owners corrected this I would probably be a regular customer.

Delicious food. Marvelous customer service. Will definitely return

My second time here, first time was for dinner (also amazing dinner food options), this time was for brunch (love that they have late ish brunch times). Food was excellent, service great, drinks good! Prices are also super reasonable too! Will definitely be coming back!

Outrageously over priced. And way to upscale for the area. Have to make at least 100k a year to eat here

The meatball parm hero tasted great but had a salty aftertaste when I finished it. I should have asked for a sauce on the side to lessen the dryness of the bread. Pasta shells with sea food was flavorful.

Brunch was amazing. Service was great ! 10/10 recommend.

Food was fantastic 🤤👌Cant go wrong with spaghetti & meatballs accompanied with a glass of wine !! Then to end the night with a strawberry cheesecake as dessert to take home.

I have been eating at Lexington Pizza Parlour since day one and I have never been disappointed!The food is amazing it’s like eating at your grandmas on a Sunday. Let’s talk about the staff FAMILIA everyday ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

The longstanding female associate is charming and sweet to have serve you, although the food is a 50/50 hit and miss. NEVER order the pizza to deliver, came cold and dry...

The food is delicious and the service is fantastic. Sammy and Patrick are amazing, always going the extra mile to provide the best experience for their customers.

Best pizza shop in all of New York. I send all of my visiting friends to Lexington pizza for the best pie in town. Friendly, family owned shop with slices to die for

I live on the block so end up taking Lexington Pizza for granted but I gotta remember to stop doing that. We went in tonight because I was craving a slice of pizza but we ended up ordering pasta (me, I had the lasagna!)and goodies such as the burrata and an order of meatballs, which we all dug into so quickly, we didn’t have a chance to take a photo!.Everything was SOOO good!!!

Great outdoor dining, pizza really hit the spot. Mixed drinks were ok, staff was really accommodating of having a kid with stroller.

Some of the best pizza & desserts!

Absolutely amazing! Everything they brought out was incredible. The wait was a little bit but it was because I ordered duck which takes longer. (Which was also amazing)

I tried placing an order over the phone and when I asked about appetizers the person that I spoke with told me I could look that info myself online because he didn’t have time to go over the menu with me? What kind of customer service is this? I’m not asking for free stuff, I’m asking for information on the things I’m going to spend my money on. Terrible customer service.Edit: The phone call took place on Saturday (11/27/2021) at 2:02PM.

Food was acceptable, pizza was very nice but was a bit disappointed with the pesto linguini. Staff were very friendly. Service was prompt. Very clean and the interior was warm and welcoming.

Food is really good, well proportions just Right. Not a long wait. Friendly waiters & desserts are amazing!

This is the best restaurant you could go to. The service is impeccable, the food is so fulfilling, and the general vibe is great. Thank you LPP for being such a staple in the neighborhood

The best cheesecake I have ever had! I mean….it’s not shareable because it’s that good….get your own jar…buy it for your friends….it’s out of this world!!

Had an amazing lunch! Definitely will be coming back 😋🍕

A very delicious the mariner source is freaking amazing the calzone is great its huge its enough to even save for later or split for 2 people

We love the food so much we decided to have our wedding reception here. They were amazing, kind, and wonderful. The food was great. All our guests were raving about how delicious and well prepared the meal was.Despite having a 20+ guests, they were able to bring out all our food hot and in a timely manner. No one went unsatisfied. We also had an incredible amount of dietary restrictions for individuals and they were able to accommodate us all.

We love Lexington Pizza Parlour!

Good food. Nice outdoor sitting. We took lamb shak and pomodoro. Food felt fresh and good but I think lamb shak was overpriced but overall nice place.

Delicious pizza. Tried the Brooklyn pepperoni and the 4 cheese. Very nice open air seating. Friendly service.

Great date night spot, their penne a la vodka is fantastic

A real treasure. The food is outstanding and great service. We have made this a regular part of trips to NYC.

Didnt like the pizza to much. The cheese tasted old.

The staff at LPP really go above and beyond. We had our sons first birthday party lunch here this past weekend and we were treated spectacularly by the hosts and and staff. The service was courteous and attentive and we always felt welcome, even when we took up a whole corener of the restaurant. Thank you for such great work!

Very tasty gnocchi! Other people I ate with had the pizza which looked great as well. Their desserts were also fabulous- if you enjoy carrot cake or cheesecake, I’d recommend getting it. Try and make a reservation ahead of time since it’s a small place and popular on the weekends.

Best Pizza Ever. Must go and must try you wouldnt regret it. The food is fresh and delicious.

Place is actually really good- thoroughly enjoyed every time I have ate at the restaurant but the first time I got takeout and I must say while the chicken parm sandwich is really good. EXTREMELY SKIMPY ON THE CHICKEN. THERE WAS ONE VERY SMALL AND THIN PIECE OF CHICKEN WITH BARELY ANY SAUCE OR CHEESE. IM NOT EXAGGERATING WHEN I SAY IT WAS 3/4 BREAD ONLY.

Thanks Paul for the recommendation and Patrick for making us feel like we were regulars! We had the blackened lemon shrimp appetizer, braised lamb special, and key lime fried ice-cream for dessert. Everything was to die for and service could not be more friendly.

My first time ordering from them and I get this. The whole topping slice right off. Not to mention from what I could taste it was bland and like cardboard. Never again.

Hi my name is khloe I love the food here and every single plate was delicious even my little sister love the pizza 🍕

Staff need training on basic etiquette.

Amazing service and food..server Sebastian will take a great care of you❤️we are happy that found this place.Thank you guys for wonderful atmosphere!

Delicious homemade pasta and a pleasant atmosphere that lens itself to any occasion, but seems a bit pricey for what you actually get.

Pizza is ok but pasta is really great. Also good selection of wine and desserts

Food is good but caught chef sticking his finger in food to test the flavor while he was cooking my chicken Marsala..smh

Great place, came here for a group dinner and we had a wonderful time, food was delicious and service was quick!

Excellent ItalianLoved the homemade pasta!Arugula , asparagus and fennel salad delicious!

Pizza is awesome.

Olive Garden quality for double the price. I got the eggplant parmigiana and some broccoli rabe. Both were disappointing. The eggplant parmigiana was deep fried, which I guess is fine if you’re into that, but I don’t. The sauce on the spaghetti it came with was way too sweet. That’s also preference but it’s not to my taste. Also the broccoli rabe was weirdly chopped up, oddly sour, and also oddly spicy. It’s not that I don’t like spice, I just found it mismatched for the dish.

Food is great and service exceptional. Will return to try the rest of the menu.

Ordered take out. Came extremely late, cold, and appeared unappetizing. Food was mediocre at best. Extremely over-priced for what it is

Very good pasta, dessert was homemade, service is good.Definitely a excellent spot

This place was my favorite restaurant during my stay in New York! So good I went twice.

Our favorite neighborhood eats

The BEST pizza Ive ever had and the food and desert is good too !🍕🍕🍕

That was the most Southbury delicious pizza Ive ever had great service I would definitely come back to this delicious Southbury pizza place

Dont waste your time going here portions are extremely small theyre overpriced been to places that were 100 times better for the same food cheaper and bigger portions

Solid pasta. Gracious service. We dined with our pups in the outside-inside space. Fun place...will be back.

Great gluten free pizza crust- seriously the best I’ve ever had. Cute atmosphere and good service

Ive tasted better pizza in Brooklyn.slices are small and skimpy on the cheese!

Good pizza, but specially it is a great place to hang out with friends.

Great value superb quality pasta pizza and a few other treats

This time around, I got the Spinach Ravioli. It was fantastic with large pieces of buffalo mozzarella. Such a large serving, I needed to take a ravioli home! Also had a nice bottle of red.

Place is awesome. Food is consistently fresh and good.

The best pizza and pasta Ive had in a long time. I got the seafood pasta and everything in that plate was cooked perfectly. The cappriociolla pizza was delicious too. Restaurant owner(?) was so sweet that he offered for us to switch to a warmer corner before I even asked. The only complaint is the happy hour drinks are quite watered down. But hey, its happy hour.

Very casual spot with great food

This place is so good. And the owner is very nice if you get a chance to chat.

Very friendly people, and great food. you will envoy there!

I absolutely adored this spot. The pizza was incredible and my never ending mimosa for 90 minutes was also yummy 😋. Our server, I think the only server, was so attentive, funny, and just perfection. I definitely will travel from Staten Island just to come back here, thats how good it was.

My meal was overcooked and over priced. The noodles were cold, the sauce was watery and the chicken tasted like rubber. Its a pizza shop cosplaying as fine dining, spend your money elsewhere.

The 4 cheese square and cheese pizza is very good. The short rib was good too.

Got a four cheese without blue cheese

One of my favorite pizza parlour excellent Prices

I ordered their braised short rib pasta and it’s amazing. Food has big serving and staff is very welcoming.

Great pizza, cocktails, and specials at a decent price

Lexington pizza is my second home !! Absolutely love this place !

Amazing Italian near Central Park. Friendly service, amazing food.

Great spot. Stumbled across this while walking with the family gave it a shot & it was marvelous. The arugula salad has a nice light flare to it. And the margarita was a thin crust - but a very sturdy crust. My daughter hasnt eaten that much of a pizza in years... Happy we went. Will return very soon.

Have been coming here for past 7 years, friendly staff can expect good food and environment. On one occasion was grabbing pizza to go and dropped it, they were super nice and remade the pie for me no additional cost.

Had the penne alla vodka with some chicken great choice

Great food. The LPP crew are very welcoming. The service was as good as the food. Highest recommendation.

I’ve ordered from here in the past. It’s such a cute little place that I honestly wanted to love it. Two times I’ve ordered from there recently several weeks apart and both times same burnt pizza. The whole bottom portion was burnt to the point where it was black and not edible. The first time I didn’t make it a big deal . Just thought we’ll they can’t all be perfect. Then last week I ordered another pie on Uber eats and it was completely burnt. I took photos, sent it in and no credit , refund or anything. I will not be ordering from this place anymore. The refund doesn’t matter. Two times burnt pizza and nothing to rectify the situation is just not good business .

Really great spot! Fresh Pasta and pizza. I enjoyed the steak special and the three meat lasagna Of course not on the same day that would be too much food but it’s great. Their out door seating is supper cute and chill. Their service is friendly and fast. Honestly their menu is great and even the special. I took my Dad here for Father’s Day. He had such a good time. The staff treated us with so such care and love. Their delivery service is always on time and the food is always hot. I love ordering take out from them.

Quick, delicious, great price for a slice

Great brunch.... French toast was amazing

Because NY Pizza is great and they make it good here !

Charming, cozy and delicious food. Lovely lunch over 🎄 break ☺️

Visited here during a trip to NY and I can’t wait to go back. One of the best Italian restaurants I’ve been to in a while!! Amazing food, amazing staff, amazing atmosphere. And you can’t skip out on dessert here, it’s a must-have!

This place is amazing. The food is delicious, everything we have tasted here is great. The customer service, omg is the best, Andrea, the guys from the kitchen, I mean everything about this place is perfect. I work near by and always go with coworkers and everything weve had is so yummy. Now we also have an account that we get points with every purchase that will help with your bill. Thank you all for the great service, we really appreciate everything you do.

I have ordered a pizza pie, and came a few times after school for a cheese slice before. Those are okay.Yesterday I had a honey, jalapeno, pepperoni corner square, and a tiramisu in a jar. The square was very good, it was balanced. I love the tiramisu, but the price is too high.Very nice service everytime Ive been there. There is a bathroom.

Lovely week night dinner on the patio, with attentive service and a perfect live music trio. A perfect stop a few blocks away from our early evening visit to the very interesting Museum of NYC.

The food was absolutely amazing! Best Food I have ever had. Service was outstanding and the deserts from Harlem Baking Co. are to die for! You will not regret coming here!

Delivery issues such as failure to seal the pizza box. Put tapes on the 3 sides of the box it’s a safety issue.

I really like this spot. Ive come here a bunch of time since its close to my job and the only decent pizza place around. I almost always get the vodka pizza. Its honestly delicious. Their meatballs are really good as well. The first time a friend and I went we ordered 2 larger pies and received an order of meatballs free. The woman who runs the place is an angel. She is super attentive and does it all. I have yet to come here and have bad service or a poor meal. The food is always really good. I really like their sangria as well. I also came once and switched it up and got chicken parm which was really good as well. Everything is pretty delicious. I feel like the place would be a lot more popular if it werent for the location, however its a good thing, because you can always get served right away. I recommend checking it out.

Their penne a la vodka was probably one of the best I’ve ever had!! Nice staff, good pricing

Our favorite neighborhood spot for steak and pizza.

Pizza was pretty flavorless and with mediocre texture, overpriced for the area imo. The bathroom was very unsanitary, and two flies constantly buzzed around my pizza. Place didn’t smell good either. Service was meh.

Its a wonderful place my daughter love it

Absolutely incredible food. I was in Sicily recently and the food here was just as good - we had Branzino, Gnocchi, Lamb Shank and all were prepared perfectly and were delicious. This place is a gem, highly recommend to all.

One of the best meals Ive had in a while. Great vibe, too.

Simple, but very friendly. Delicious lobster raviolis.

Another keeper! Fresh, quality food,and clean restaurant. The service is fast, and friendly.The GF pizzas are not amazing ,but the rest is excellent.They will adapt to your needs, and taste.Italian restaurant with a definite French touch ( the chef/owner is French)We are in NYC where the level of choice is extremely high, and competitive, but definitely a runner up.If you are a fine gourmet, I am sur you will appreciate the work behind the food without any gimmicks.

This used to be a great spot to grab a slice of pizza, but the quality of their pizza slice has diminished significantly. Its on par with the $1 pizza joints around town that cater to high schoolers and cheapie people. Their sit-down restaurant food, however, remains favorable and worth trying.

Delicious pizza , wish they delivered to harlem!

Intimate setting, attentive friendly service, beautiful Italian food

I forgot to take a pic but this is a real Italian diner that has plenty of clean outdoor seating. The cheese pizza is delicious. Real cheese pizza!!?

Great pizza! We came in winter and they had seated outdoor tables. Reasonable prices!

Good food, people, prices, atmosphere.

A local treasure

We went in the late summer early fall and the atmosphere was wonderful! Perfect casual date night spot. The service was great and even the manager came out to talk to us and circled throughout the restaurant to other tables as well. Decently priced and the food was great. Awesome find!

Outstanding authentic Italian food. courteous service . pizzas are to die for . Must visit

This place is a tiny gem! Great food and service. Today we had the burrata, short ribs over risotto and tiramisu....all delicious!! Cant wait to go back. 😊

This was a great place! Had gluten free pasta and so many options. I ate with my family and all 5 of us had a different dish and all of us enjoyed what we ate. I would recommend this to anyone traveling in the area for a bite to eat!

Pleasant service food was delicious and quick

I have to say this is the best pizza in the area! They are so friendly to the people in the neighborhood and and I cannot tell you how much I love their pizza and the arugula salad! Don’t miss out on a great restaurant!

Favorite local place to eat Italian food.The burrata salad is delicious !

Pizza delivered cold and had a literal fly in my pizza box when it arrived. This should not happen.

Everything was great! Owner was very attentive to patrons. Looking forward to going back.

Great lunch place. Hidden gem

Possibly the worst pizza I have ever had. Arrived late, cold, meatball slices jumbled on 1-2 slices, hardly any sauce and hardly any cheese. I have had better pizza from 99 cent slices. The main food menu is great. They should take out their pizza ovens and stick to mamas cooking. Very disappointed-

My guy and I agreed that the pizza is bad. Dont do it. The carrot cake was good but one slice had a hair on it.

Loved the place! The food here is amazing. The staffs are so wonderful! And their chocolate cake with vanilla icecream is truly ❤ . This is going to be my favorite pizza/dessert place from now on!

Staff is always welcoming and attentive. Food is consistently delicious, whether its on their regular menu or a special for the day.

Holy Smokes! This place just keeps getting better - and interestingly, its not the pizza that gets better, but the other menu items. For the best dishes served above 96th Street, head to Lexington Pizza Parlour. Note to owner: you may want to modify the name as it doesnt tell your story.

The pasta was delicious!

Large variety of fabulous dishes at very affordable prices. Staff is quite amiable, going the extra mile to be helpful. Flexible menu includes daily specials. Pleasant ambiance.

Really disappointed . Our order was all messed up and spent quite a bit of money . We ordered from here before Many times for pizza especially, for large orders and then for pizza and regular food too so I have spent a significant amount here . The food has been good . This time however our pizza was wrong , missing our dessert and some drinks . Pizza was super cold almost like it had been made another day ? You could tell there was no care in this order . It’s going to be hard to order from here again .

Great experience! Vinegar sauce on prosciutto and arugula pizza is a masterpiece.

Decent lunch spot, not too crowded.

It is okay. Staff is friendly. Food is average.

Amazing food, and kind staff! We go once a week!

Fun nite out. Outside dining the best!!

Food was absolutely delicious! Service was great.

Excellent pizza!Customer service (water refills, busing of table) seemed short-handed.The food makes this restaurant worth another visit!

This is a gem of a restaurant!! Everything is so good, you can close your eyes and point anywhere on the menu, and regardless of your selection, you will be dazzled!! BTW, the pizzas are wonderful!!

I just ordered the chicken marsala for delivery, for the second time in a week. If anything it was even better this time. My wife is similarly addicted to the penne with vodka sauce. This hidden gem of an Italian shouldnt be missed.

We rarely come to this place but we just went recently here... u guys mist try their rice ball. Super good. We only go here during rainy or cold days 😁 eating warm food makes its delicious and this place is very cozy.

$3 for a plain slice without much sauce or flavor is too high. Taste wasn’t worth the money spent. Staff was friendly though!